Rabbi Trusts as a Compensation Tool
Written by
Andrew Hart, CTFA, TEP
November 20, 2026 · 9 min read
Few things unnerve corporate boards more than seeking shareowner approval at an annual general meeting for the company’s executive compensation plan. Not only are these votes a referendum on how much companies are paying their top executives, they also indicate whether the plans align with shareowner interests for long-term value and limited dilution. No votes are rare, but when they occur, they signal to the market that the board and the company owners are out of sync.
Corporate boards devote significant resources and time to creating compensation plans for their senior executives to help them avoid these embarrassing situations. Dedicated committees work with consultants to formulate compensation strategies that both align management incentives with shareowner interests and adhere to applicable laws and listing standards.1 Comp committees approve and oversee millions of dollars in compensation for corporate executives using these processes.
They go to all this trouble because well-crafted plans can stimulate corporate decisions and actions that generate significant value. Apple’s 2003 plan to pay Steve Jobs solely with restricted shares, for example, coincided closely with the company’s market capitalization growing at a compound annual rate of 92% over the next five years.2 Conversely, corporate graveyards are littered with the remains of enterprises whose compensation policies directed senior management toward their ultimate demise.
Advantages of a Rabbi Trust
Companies typically pay their senior executives with cash and company securities. The goal is to give the executive current rewards while using share-based awards to align their interests with those of shareowners. The mechanisms used, such as stock options, stock-appreciation rights, and restricted shares, can also cause a divergence of interests by diluting external shareowners’ equity position by giving shares to senior executives.
Using a so-called rabbi trust enables a sponsor to break from the ambiguity of traditional performance targets in exchange for a more targeted approach based upon more measurable outcomes. Named for an IRS private letter ruling issued to a congregation that set aside deferred pay to retain its rabbi,3 this type of trust enables a sponsor to reward specific behaviors, results, or transactions tied to specific triggers. It also has been used to supplement and smooth retirement income and to protect senior executives in the case of a change in control of the company.
Regardless of the reasons, there is little need for a link to the sponsor’s equity in such trusts because in most cases, benefits will accrue after the executive has departed the sponsor,4 thereby eliminating the risk of dilution for external shareowners. Consequently, these trusts can hold alternative investment vehicles such as shares of closely held stock, real estate, interests in private equity, private debt, or hedge funds. Alternatively, a sponsor may prefund a trust for the benefit of an executive’s survivors with company-owned life insurance (COLI) policies purchased on the participants’ lives.
The flexibility of the rabbi trust to create long-term value for sponsor and recipient is baked into a structure that has evolved through IRS rulings and federal statute. Section 409A5 of the Internal Revenue Code (the IRC), for example, outlines the rules for nonqualified deferred compensation (NQDC) plans and the irrevocable grantor trusts that typically characterize rabbi trusts.
Unlike many other NQDC plans that are simply promises to pay later, a sponsor using a rabbi trust can earmark and invest assets to fully fund future liabilities, even while deferring tax liabilities on the benefits. And because the assets are fully funding the trust and in its possession, the sponsor does not have to scramble to raise and deliver the funds to make the payment. Moreover, a sponsor can add assets to a rabbi trust over time, and most such plans are designed to receive ongoing contributions.
Cost of Non-Compliance
There are important stipulations, however, and the cost of noncompliance can be steep.
The first and least painful of this pyramid of pain is the legal prohibition against a sponsor going back on its decision once the assets are in the trustee’s possession. In turn, the trustee holds legal title for the assets, thus safeguarding the beneficiary from a “change of heart” on the part of a company, its board, or new owners.
The second, slightly more painful outcome is one no sponsor would wish to incur. Per the so-called “economic benefit doctrine,” trust assets remain subject to the claims of the sponsor’s general creditors if the sponsor becomes insolvent. It is the accessibility in bankruptcy, however, that endows rabbi trusts with their tax-deferral benefits.
Section 409A is where the most severe penalties and restrictions for misuse are located. Topping that list is the prohibition against tying the funding trigger to the financial health of the sponsor. Subsection (b)(2) of the statute immediately rescinds all tax deferral and other benefits of the trust and imposes taxes and penalties on the beneficiary as though the trust’s income was taxable but not paid since its origination.6
The parties to the trust cannot manufacture or extend a risk of forfeiture to manipulate the timing of taxation. The only acceptable distribution triggers are a) separation from service, b) death, c) disability, d) change in control, e) unforeseeable emergency, or f) a specified period or fixed schedule that is objectively determinable at the time of deferral. Rabbi trusts located outside the United States and holding assets for NQDC purposes automatically lose deferral under Section 409A(b)(1), and the vested deferred amounts are treated as current income, with the penalties and interest added.
Finally, with few exceptions, 409A prohibits both acceleration and delay of any payments once the time and form of distributions are fixed. Acceleration can occur only under limited hardship provisions. Conversely, a sponsor cannot delay payment, either, even if it does not have the cash available to fulfill its obligation toward the trust.
Two Types of Rabbi Trusts
Sponsors have two options for structuring rabbi trusts. They can use either an “ordinary” or “springing” structure. Both are incorporated into Internal Revenue Service (IRS) model trust language. The difference between the two is based on when the trust is fully funded.
Ordinary trusts get funded at or near the time of deferral. Thereafter, the assets sit in the trust throughout the life of the trust, unless the sponsor files for bankruptcy protection, when general creditors are able to access the funds, as described above.
Springing trusts are structured but remain unfunded until a defined triggering event legally obligates the sponsor to fully fund the trust. In other words, the sponsor would retain use of the assets for its own liquidity until the trigger event occurs.
Planning for Liquidity for Illiquid Rabbi Trust Assets
Investment strategies that focus on illiquid assets have consequences. As noted above, a sponsor is legally obligated to fund a rabbi trust when triggered, regardless of how much it has on hand in the form of liquid assets at the trigger moment. Consequently, sponsors can prepare an investment policy that matches the liquidity of trust assets with expected distributions. Sponsors should specifically plan for the following.
- Map the payment schedule. Know when each participant can reach a distribution trigger and how much the plan could owe if they do in any particular year.
- Carefully manage trust liquidity. An adviser or investment manager should plan to cover near-term obligations with cash and/or securities that can be sold without incurring substantial price declines, or the forced sale of a private investment vehicle.
- Watch redemption terms. Investment funds that allow periodic redemptions are easier to manage for expected and unexpected distributions and can prevent drawdowns of funds with long lockups and where liquidity gates are possible.
- Plan for valuations. Private assets need a fair market value for trust statements and reporting. Agree up front on who provides it and how often.
Onboarding
A key benefit to sponsors who are AET clients is the ability to integrate and private label AET’s onboarding system into their own through an application programming interface (API). The API also enables their platforms to embed and private label custody and trust administration visibility directly into their own applications.
NQDC recordkeepers, third-party administrators (TPAs), executive compensation consultants, or insurance distributors placing COLI-funded plans have needs beyond a simple trustee. They need integrated trustee infrastructure to effect quick onboarding, that remains in a directed posture that enables company advisers to retain client relationships, and that offers to custody hard assets like private-company shares ahead of an acquisition. Bank trustees generally don’t offer such services.
To expedite the onboarding process, sponsors should gather the following before the client talks to a trustee.
- The trust document, or a draft. Most rabbi trusts use IRS model language in Revenue Procedure 92-64. American Estate & Trust does not draft trust documents, but we can review them and refer clients to attorneys who do.
- Who directs investments. The company can name the investment manager and the company officer who gives instructions and signs on the company’s behalf.
- The asset plan. The company should prepare an outline for the allocation of closely held stock, real estate, or private investments the trust may hold and compare cash flow expectations with future trust distributions.
- The contribution and payment schedules. A contribution and payment schedule should incorporate and describe initial funding, expected contributions, vesting, and distribution triggers.
- Company and owner information. The trustee completes AML and KYC review on the company and the people who control it before the trust opens.
The bottom line
- A rabbi trust adds flexibility to the kind of assets invested in the plan. Compensation tied to company shares is less important when the benefits accrue after the executive departs from the company.
- Dropping the trust costs the executive real protection. An informal promise to pay from the company to the executive may keep the tax deferral provision intact, but it will eliminate the protection against a change of control or a change of heart on the part of new owners.
- A directed trustee keeps your adviser on the account. The company can appoint its adviser as investment manager while an independent trustee holds title to the trust.
- Illiquid assets need liquidity planning. Section 409A payment dates are fixed, so the trust needs liquid assets to fully fund benefits on time.
If your company is considering a rabbi trust and you need a trustee, talk to our trust team.
American Estate & Trust (AET) is a Nevada trust company specializing in the administration of rabbi trusts. AET provides branded portals for both companies and employees, ensuring that onboarding, funding, and administration of the trust and its assets are understood by all parties. AET also provides API integrations allowing your company, or your platform, to embed custody and trust administration visibility directly into your own applications. As a custodian, AET is an expert in the administration and custody of both alternative assets and marketable securities.
Find out today how American Estate & Trust can help you with rabbi trusts.
Footnotes
-
Compensation plans that are untethered to company performance risk shareowner rejection of the plans. Boards work closely with large shareowners to avoid this type of outcome. ↩
-
See AAPL 10-Ks on file with EDGAR at the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission for the periods ranging from early March 2003 to early March 2008. ↩
-
See PLR 8113107 from the Internal Revenue Service in 1980, and published into model trust language by Revenue Procedure 92-64 in 1992. ↩
-
Participants may opt for scheduled or fixed-date distributions which theoretically may occur prior to the executive’s departure. ↩
-
Section 409A of the IRC was created as part of the American Jobs Creation Act of 2004. See Rabbi Trusts, Funding, 409A Rules, and Choosing a Trustee for more information. ↩
-
Penalties for failing to adhere to Section 409A rules include a) all vested deferred amounts are immediately included in the participant’s income, b) a 20% tax penalty imposed on the total amount, and c) premium interest charged at the IRS underpayment rate plus 1%, calculated as if the amounts had been taxable when first deferred or vested. ↩